Brand operations

How suppliers sort a small D2C account, and what you can change

CIPS describes supplier preferencing, from Steele and Court, as the supplier's view of the account. Value is your share of their sales. Attractiveness covers standing, growth, payment behaviour and how much attention the account needs. A D2C buyer can score both, then choose a supplier or change how the account is run.

A long sales bar shows a small carton on a thin slice and a larger carton to the right. A paid invoice, forecast, specification stack and change note sit beside the small carton.

Key takeaways

Classify the account by your share of the supplier's sales and by standing, growth, payment behaviour and how much attention the work needs.

Concentrate spend, name a future order, price a second source, or keep a high-share account easy to serve.

A supplier does not sort customers by how badly you need the goods. CIPS describes the Supplier Preferencing Matrix, developed by Steele and Court, as "a model to view the relationship from the supplier's perspective." Comprara dates that concept to 1996 and names Paul Steele and Brian Court. The matrix puts customers into four cells by account value and account attractiveness. On the CIPS diagram, attractiveness runs up the vertical axis and the relative value of the business runs along the horizontal.

CIPS treats value as financial contribution and attractiveness as strategic importance. The Academy of Procurement defines relative value as "the value of the account as a percentage of the supplier's total sales." The same page notes that the biggest customers need not always get the best deals, which is why sales share and attractiveness stay separate axes rather than one ranking.

That split is what a growing D2C brand can use. The outcomes buyers care about are lead times, minimum order quantities (MOQs), payment terms and allocation when stock is tight. No source reviewed here measures those outcomes by quadrant. The sources describe the supplier's class for the account and what the buyer can change.

A risk map does not say you are preferred

Gradezup, a CIPS exam-practice site rather than CIPS, draws the contrast in one line. Kraljic identifies which categories warrant a strategic relationship, the high-impact and high-risk group. Supplier preferencing tells you whether the supplier sees you as a core customer or an exploitable one. Supply risk belongs on the Kraljic side.

SAP Help, in the Ariba category-management guide, defines attractiveness as how appealing the buying organisation is, influenced by reputation, growth potential and ease of doing business. It defines relative value as the monetary value or strategic importance of the spend. That second definition puts strategic importance on the value axis, which is where CIPS puts financial contribution. This article follows CIPS for the split, and the sales-share definition for the horizontal axis. SAP's questionnaire asks about strategic importance once. Strategic importance is counted twice only if you also score it on the CIPS attractiveness axis.

Where the two maps clash

A buyer-side risk map can rate an input as critical while the supplier rates you as a nuisance. Few alternatives, a part that stops orders if it is late, and a small, fiddly account can all be true at once. Score that supplier first, and do not treat the clash as a measured result on who receives stock. CIPS says that if the supplier views the account as less significant, you might face higher prices and lower prioritisation during peak demand.

A hypothetical share you can recalculate

The figures below are hypothetical. They assume the full £40,000 a year is spent with each maker in turn, not split across the three, and that each sales figure is for the same year.

With a contract manufacturer on £8 million of sales, the share is 40,000 divided by 8,000,000, which is 0.5%. With a mid-size maker on £2 million, it is 40,000 divided by 2,000,000, which is 2%. With a specialist on £1 million, it is 40,000 divided by 1,000,000, which is 4%.

Comprara uses an account value of between 1% and 3% of total sales to mark the division between high and low value accounts, though this depends in part on the structure of the industry. The Academy of Procurement page is largely the same text, so this is one consultancy's rule of thumb, not two independent studies. On that wording, 0.5% sits below the band, 2% sits inside it, and 4% sits above it. Comprara's account-type checklists also include "The account is more than 2% of their total sales." under both Core and Exploitable, so that line does not separate those two cells from each other.

The sales share does not finish the classification. Against Comprara's band, 0.5% is low on value whether or not the paperwork is tidy. Paid invoices, a forecast and a held specification do not enter the sales-share sum, so they leave the percentage where it is. Attractiveness, covered in the next section, is the other axis. These sources do not give a formula that converts those records into a score.

How to score without flipping the axes

Keep value as the percentage. Do not replace it with a 1 to 5 rating. If the supplier will not give annual sales, mark the figure as your estimate and do not pretend the percentage is exact. Leave an unknown sales total blank rather than entering zero, and still score the attractiveness factors you can evidence.

Rate each factor from a record you hold. Paid invoices show payment behaviour. A forecast tied to an order you will place shows growth. A specification pack, and how often it changes, shows how much attention the account needs. Comprara treats an account as less attractive when it is stagnant and low in sales value, and when it needs a high level of attention. Where the labels overlap, keep standing for reputation, brand prestige and kudos by association, keep the growth record for growth potential and profitable sales growth, and keep the attention record for ease of doing business. Profitability, contract stability, ethics and willingness to collaborate come from Gradezup and Examova, exam-preparation sites rather than CIPS. Leave each of those blank unless a contract, a margin figure or a written policy sits beside it.

SAP Ariba gives category managers a questionnaire on both dimensions. SAP's training material says that after the assessment the manager can adapt engagement, depending on whether the supplier sees the organisation as a core partner or a secondary account. A D2C brand can do the same on one page: the percentage, then a line on each factor you can evidence.

One free tool, ProcurementTools, rates both axes from 1 to 5. It puts relative value on the vertical axis and attractiveness on the horizontal, the reverse of CIPS. It also describes the high-value, low-attractiveness cell as a supplier that may invest to grow the account despite low attractiveness. CIPS calls that cell Exploitable. Do not use that tool's axis direction or that cell description.

The four CIPS cells are Nuisance, Development, Exploitable and Core. Nuisance is low value and low attractiveness. Development is low value and high attractiveness. Exploitable is high value and low attractiveness. Core is high value and high attractiveness.

What to change in each quadrant

Nuisance is the small, hard account. CIPS says buyers in this category should aim to increase spending to raise the account attractiveness, or consider alternative suppliers. CIPS's own wording mixes the axes: extra spend changes your share of sales more directly than it changes attractiveness. Read with the sales-share definition, the choice is to concentrate spend until the percentage is meaningful, or to move the work to a supplier for whom the same annual figure is a larger share. That is supplier choice.

Development is the small account the supplier still wants. CIPS says buyers should focus on discussing future value and opportunities, so the supplier stays interested and supportive. A forward buy, or a one-page forecast tied to an order you will actually place, makes that future value specific. The Academy of Procurement lists some willingness to negotiate terms, and an eagerness to talk about package deals or extra work, among the signs of a development account. Those items belong to a checklist that needs five or more signs, so they do not class the account on their own, and they are not proof that terms will move.

Exploitable is the account with volume and little appeal. CIPS's guidance for this cell is to avoid over-leveraging their position and to enhance alignment, especially if they supply core products. The Academy of Procurement's warning signs include spend rising faster than your demand, and an account manager targeted on margin rather than market share. Those signs do not, on their own, class the account. If they appear, get a price from a second source so this supplier is not the only one you can buy from.

Core is the account the supplier treats as worth keeping. On the sales-share definition used here, Core is also high value, so a small share does not qualify. Comprara's signs include a dedicated key account manager, supplier assets specific to the account, the supplier seeking longer-term commitments, and use of the account as a reference site. Paying to the agreed date, a stable specification and a forecast that matches orders you will place can support the attractiveness side. They do not move a low share into Core.

Payment is a factor, and a cash cost

Gradezup, an exam-preparation site rather than CIPS, lists payment behaviour as an attractiveness factor. The record is invoices paid to the agreed date. Paying earlier than that date moves cash out of the business sooner.

Score the accounts that can stop you

Do not put the whole supplier list on the matrix. Score a category when the spend is large enough that the share might meet Comprara's band, or when a missed delivery would stop orders.

For each of those accounts, check:

  • Your annual spend and the supplier's annual sales, for the same period. Mark the sales figure if it is your estimate.
  • The percentage, calculated from those two numbers.
  • Whether a 1% to 3% division even fits that industry, or is only a prompt.
  • Evidence on the attractiveness factors you can show: paid invoices, a forecast, a specification pack, and how often you change it.
  • The CIPS cell, with attractiveness vertical and sales share horizontal.
  • One move: a supplier sized to the spend, a forward buy, a second source, or a cleaner way of ordering so a core or development account stays attractive.

Sources

  1. CIPS, Supplier Preferencing Matrix cips.org CIPS says that if the supplier sees an account as less significant, the buyer might face higher prices and lower prioritisation during peak demand. This is hedged with 'might' and is not measured. It qualifies the article's statement that the matrix does not say who gets stock in a shortage.
  2. SAP Help Portal, SAP Ariba Category Management User Guide, Supplier Preferencing help.sap.com Attractiveness is how appealing the buying organization is to the supplier, influenced by factors like reputation, growth potential, and ease of doing business.
  3. SAP Learning, Managing Category Suppliers learning.sap.com After the assessment, each supplier sits in a preferencing category, so the category manager can adapt engagement depending on whether that supplier sees the organisation as a core partner or a secondary account.
  4. SAP Community, SAP UX Q3/2025 Update, Part 5 community.sap.com SAP calls supplier preferencing an established approach that helps organizations understand how they are perceived by vendors.
  5. Comprara, Supplier Relationship Management: Is Bigger Always Better? comprara.com.au Comprara's checklists of account-type signs include the item that the account is more than 2% of the supplier's total sales. On the page this item appears under both the Core account and Exploitable account lists. It is a consultancy heuristic, and no method is stated.
  6. Academy of Procurement, Is Bigger Always Better? academyofprocurement.com Largely the same text as S5, so not separate confirmation of shared claims.
  7. Examova, CIPS L4M6 study preview, Portfolio Analysis Techniques examova.com Exam-preparation site, not CIPS. Attractiveness factors named: profitability, growth, contract stability, ethics, and willingness to collaborate.
  8. Gradezup, CIPS L4M6 practice paper gradezup.com Lists ease of doing business, brand prestige and payment behaviour as attractiveness factors.
  9. ProcurementTools.org, Supplier Preferencing Model procurementtools.org Each supplier gets a 1 to 5 rating for relative value and for account attractiveness.

Useful answers

Questions operators ask

If you only know a supplier's sales are above a figure, what share can you state?

If you only know that a supplier's sales are above a figure, your share is lower than the percentage that figure implies. That is an upper bound, not an exact share. You can compare the bound with Comprara's 1% to 3% band, which Comprara says depends in part on the structure of the industry.

About the author

Eddie Cheng

Eddie Cheng founded Penang Media and co-owns VIBAe. He writes from the agency and brand sides of ecommerce growth, connecting paid acquisition with stock, margins, cash flow and contribution profit.

More from Eddie Cheng