All letters
Issue 18

They raised spend. New customers didn't move

A brand owner I spoke to recently asked me to look over their ad account.

They'd raised weekly spend from about $8k to about $12k.

New customers didn't move.

Same number as before. So each new customer was now costing them about 50% more.

They wanted to know what had gone wrong.

Here's what I think happened.

The ads hadn't changed. Same creative. Same angles.

The budget went up, but what people were seeing stayed exactly the same.

That's the whole problem.

It's an easy mistake to make. When ads are working, putting more money behind them feels like the obvious next step.

And for a while it can be.

But a bigger budget doesn't send the platform off to find new buyers for you.

In my experience it doesn't work that way when the ads stay the same.

The ads are what find the buyers. The budget mostly decides how often they get shown.

If the ads aren't reaching anyone new, a bigger budget just means paying more to reach the same people again.

People who've already seen them. People who've already decided.

You see it in the numbers first. Spend goes up. New customers sit still. The cost of each one climbs.

So you put more money in, and you get the same customers out.

The fix I suggested wasn't cutting spend.

It was changing what the spend is behind.

For them, I'd put the testing money into video. New creative, so the ads get a real chance at people the old ones weren't reaching.

Video isn't the special part here. The point is putting something new in front of people.

I don't know yet how it'll play out for them. That's the honest version.

But I'd make the same call again.

A bigger budget doesn't find new buyers.

New ads do.

So if you're about to raise spend, look at the ads first.

Has anything changed since the last time you scaled?

If not, you're probably about to pay more for the same people.

It's a quick check to do before you spend the money.

Hit reply and tell me the last time you raised spend and what happened to new customers.

— Eddie